top of page

SERVICES

Policy

Board policy is the primary way a school board sets expectations for the district, yet policy is often written by staff, who naturally favor autonomy, or advanced by individual board members, who naturally favor oversight - and sometimes pet projects. As an independent facilitator, I help boards and district leaders find consensus on policy reforms that hold the system accountable while leaving the superintendent and staff the flexibility they need to lead. The result is board policy that is legally current, clearly delineates the board’s role from the superintendent’s, and ensures accountability for implementation.

WHAT BOARDS OFTEN TELL ME

“Our policy manual has not been reviewed in a decade and we do not know where to start.”

“We keep adopting policies that read like administrative procedures.”

“Our policies describe what staff should do, but not what the board expects to see.”

WHAT BALANCED POLICY LOOKS LIKE

Accountability for Results, Autonomy to Lead

The board holds the district accountable for the performance of every school “while empowering educators to implement effective strategies, innovations and interventions.” The policy states the school measures “should not be used as a punitive measure" and most importantly ensures that no low performing school is left unaddressed without district intervention.

The board evaluates the superintendent each year on mutually agreed goals. Performance objectives, including systemwide academic and financial results, count for at least 40% of the rating, and the board’s leadership survey for no more than 60%. Anonymous 360 and climate surveys inform the superintendent’s professional development plan without affecting the rating.

RESULTS IN GWINNETT COUNTY

A Board That Now Governs Through Policy

2

substantive policies adopted in the year before engagement of BK Consulting

(Sept 2024 - Sept 2025)

9

substantive policies adopted in the year since BK Consulting engagement & facilitation of Policy Committee

(Oct 2025 - Oct 2026)

Both counts leave out routine legal compliance updates to policies. BK-supported policies included a new academic accountability framework, a revised superintendent evaluation policy, the district’s fund balance and budget policies, a restructured board committee charter, a new policy on multilingual learners and long term capital planning. All policies were approved unanimously by the Board. Over the same period, the share of board work session time spent on policy rose from 6% to 20%.

OFFERINGS

How I Support Board Policy

Policy manual review

Every policy scored against a consistent rubric, a prioritized revision plan, and a report of findings.

Recent example: Las Cruces (NM)

Targeted policy series review

Benchmarking and redlined revisions for one section of the manual, such as board governance or policy development, with an analysis of the current state of the policies and a summary of recommendations.

Recent examples: Baltimore City (MD), Tempe (AZ)

New policy development

Research, peer and national benchmarking, and draft policy on emerging issues such as artificial intelligence and school safety.

Recent example: Multiple districts

Policy committee support

Agenda planning, research, facilitation of feedback from stakeholders and drafting support for the board’s policy committee across the year.

Recent example: Gwinnett County (GA)

Are you looking to strengthen your board's policy work?

Let’s talk about what your board needs next.

ben@benkleban.com  ·  Walla Walla, Washington

  • LinkedIn

© Ben Kleban Consulting LLC  |  All rights reserved

bottom of page